Question
I have read your books and they got me through the phone screening. Now I am going into the in-person interview with the hiring manager and I’m concerned how to get myself an edge over my competition. I am ready to start demonstrating that I can do this job. I do not have enough information about the interviewer to determine their comfort level. Should I react “normally” during this interview or should I try and divert conversation to how I would do the job?
Nick’s Reply
First of all, you can only do this with the hiring manager, not with HR or with a recruiter. (I’m concerned other readers may try to generalize my advice. This will work only with an interviewer who’s fully immersed in the work at hand.)
Second, never “divert” a conversation — not on the phone, not in a video meeting and not in person. “Guide” is more like it. It takes a little finesse, and a little diplomacy to lead into showing how you would do the job. If you’re unsure how to bring it up, here’s the first question managers don’t see coming from a job candidate.
First question
Ask the interviewer, “Would you like me to give you an idea of how I’d tackle this job?”
Then take the interviewer’s lead. It’s important to ask permission. A manager that doesn’t grasp what you’re offering is not likely to entertain the suggestion. It’s better that you know. A manager that gets it will probably help you with your “demonstration” by actually turning it into a discussion.
How you handle this will determine whether you stand out as the best candidate the manager can hire.
Second question
Job candidates are understandably nervous in interviews because of this disadvantage: they don’t know enough about the manager they’re talking to. If you don’t know anything about the interviewer, let them take the lead in the discussion, then at a comfortable point ask the second question managers don’t see coming. (There are actually two parts to this “getting to know the manager” strategy.)
Start with: “What brought you to this company and to managing this team?”
Let the manager talk. Take a little break and listen for information you can use.
Then, “What it is about your current project that you find most challenging?”
This is a good way to steer the discussion toward the work — and to how the manager likes to approach it. Learning about the manager’s background will tip you off about how to discuss the work yourself. Other candidates are not likely to have this kind of insight about the manager. That gives you an edge. Use it.
Third question
Not all managers feel comfortable with candidates who are ready to show their stuff. You have to make them feel it’s their choice to let you do this. So be gentle. If you’re talking with a good manager, they’ll give you some room.
Remember: never come off like a know-it-all, or like someone who thinks they’re going to step in and “take over.” Take it slow. Show what you can do “with permission,” and then ask the manager the third magic question. Ask for their feedback.
For example, once you’re done discussing your plan for the job, ask, “If I were already your employee and presented you with this rough plan for doing the job, what guidance, instruction or advice would you give me?”
The manager’s reaction and response will tell you whether you’re a serious candidate for the job.
Managers don’t see these questions coming because they’re not accustomed to job candidates that are fully prepared to stand out in the interview. They don’t expect candidates who are ready to roll up their sleeves and have a working meeting with a manager about the job they want.
There are actually lots of good questions managers “don’t see coming” from job candidates. What are the best ones you know and use? What do you offer in a job interview that shows you’re ready to hit the ground running?
: :


You’re obviously the real deal by the diplomatic way you navigate the conversation my guess is this only comes from years of experience and successful placement of many candidates. It’s a very subtle skill but a rare talent. Your advice is invaluable in a world of make believe online experts.
One question I would add to that working meeting is: “What would we both look at in six months to decide whether this was a good hire?” It connects the proposed plan, the manager’s feedback and the eventual work. It also gives the employer something to revisit when deciding which requirements really mattered. That missing feedback loop is the subject of my essay The Hiring Blind Spot, which readers can find here: https://johnelijah1.substack.com/p/the-hiring-blind-spot
The third question is the one I’d steal. If the manager answers it like you already work there, you’ve stopped being a candidate and started being the answer to their problem. We run a job board for traveling trades workers, and the same thing happens on a jobsite walk: a foreman who talks through how they’d sequence the work stands out from the ones who just hand over a resume. That’s also the moment to have your number ready, because once they want you the rate talk gets a lot easier. Here’s a tool for working out what rate to ask for before the offer comes.
Allow me to add to the list questions that a manager wouldn’t see coming:
1. What have you personally accomplished in the last 12 months that makes you qualified to evaluate my performance?
2. How many people have left your team in the past two years, and how many left because of your management?
3. What would your current salespeople say is your biggest weakness as a leader?
4. When was the last time you admitted to your team that you made a bad decision?
5. If I called your three most recent former employees, what would they tell me about working for you?
6. What percentage of your sales team actually achieved quota last year? I don’t want the company average. I want the actual percentage.
7. If your product is as competitive as you claim, why aren’t more of your salespeople making their numbers?
8. How much of your revenue comes from genuine new business versus existing customers that your salespeople inherited?
9. Are your quotas based on market opportunity or whatever number finance needs to satisfy investors?
10. What specific evidence do you have that this territory can produce the revenue you’re expecting?
11. Why is this position really open? And please don’t give me the standard ‘growth opportunity’ explanation.
12. How many people have failed in this position, and what makes you believe the problem was them rather than the company?
13. What percentage of your salespeople would voluntarily choose to work for you again?
14. What is the most expensive mistake you’ve made as a sales leader, and who paid the price?
15. If your top salesperson resigned tomorrow, would you know the real reason, or would you blame compensation?
16. What are the three biggest reasons customers choose your competitors, and what have you actually done to fix them?
17. If your value proposition is so compelling, why does your sales team need to discount to close?
18. How much revenue have you lost because your organization couldn’t deliver what sales promised?
19. What is your competitive advantage that a well-funded competitor couldn’t replicate within 18 months?
20. If I joined tomorrow, what would I discover in the first 90 days that you’re deliberately not telling me today?
21. Why should I risk my professional reputation joining your organization?
22. What evidence do you have that your leadership is producing results rather than simply benefiting from the work of talented salespeople?
23. If your compensation plan is so attractive, why do you have to recruit experienced salespeople instead of retaining the ones you already have?
24. If I outperform your expectations, will you reward me, or will you simply raise my quota until I fail?
25. You’ve spent the last hour determining whether I’m good enough to work here. What have you demonstrated that should convince me you’re good enough to work for?
26. What have you demonstrated that should convince me you’re good enough to work for?
Great questions but if asked as directly as written I suspect would lead to a very short interview.
Fair point. Although a shorter interview isn’t necessarily a bad outcome. Sometimes you learn more from the questions people don’t want to answer.